Wednesday, January 31, 2018

What's the big deal with the X-Men's Dark Phoenix Saga? Should you even care that its next up in the X-Men movie cycle?

The Dark Phoenix Saga of the X-Men comics happened in the seventies. People are still talking about it. Rather, comic book geeks are still talking about it, and they form the core (made up of mostly men and boys) of the support for comic books in general. And now, the Marvel movies are going to explore this sad tale of love, loss, and the power that corrupts. But some of you out there who watch "The Gifted" or "Legion" or any other offshoot byproduct staged in the X-Men universe might be wondering: what's the big deal? Why is this an even buzzworthy topic when we've seen "Days of Future Past" and have X-Men that can shoot destructive beams from their eyes, levitate metal objects, or take control of people with their minds. What makes Jean Grey so special aside from the fact that she tore stuff up in the terrible X-Men 3? Is Dark Phoenix just an excuse for Jean Grey to tear more stuff up? Does the destruction porn ever stop or are there new levels of destruction porn? These are all very good questions.

First off, before there was Jubilee, and Angel, and every "whatsits" character with porcupine quills popping out of their face, there were founding members of the X-Men: Charles Xavier and Jean Grey to name a very short list. Chris Claremont (who was a writer in the mid 70's) gave Jean Grey some greatly enhanced abilities. As a result, Jean Grey was far more powerful than anyone else on the team of X-people. If you haven't noticed, boys and guys who are nerds (this is a broad realization but it's true...please believe me) like hot chicks that can fight. Yes...it's a thing. They don't like Audrey Hepburn "elegant lady" types. They want (and have for decades) liked tough talking hot babes (who still shave their armpits and legs) but who know how to take a punch in high heels (Wonder Woman) while being "edgy" (Netflix Jessica Jones or a young Jessica Alba). Bonus points if the heroine has red hair. Yes...this is a thing. Please don't shoot the messenger. Call it a fetish if that makes any more sense. Nerds are just narcissists that haven't discovered "edgy" yet.

As a result of the increased power and the fact that Jean Grey fit all the stereotypes named above, she was a popular character. And adding to all of that power was the underlying mystery of where it was coming from. Claremont (to his brilliance) seeded the story run with hints that Jean's growing power was corrupting her. She was kind of falling under the influence of a malevolent entity. "The Dark Phoenix saga" is a chronicle of all of that drama. And for you writers out there, I also want to mention that the writing in this particular series was as solid as they come, the stakes were very high, and Jean Grey perished (which at the time was significant because comic book deaths were still a kind of novelty). So all of those things just fed into why this tale was so epic.

The drawing in these issues was incredible too. There was a George Perez-like attention to detail with every panel strewn with things that you just don't see in today's comic books. The story arc had no tie-ins either. It was nine issues with an extra large conclusion. Characters who are popular X-Men today made their first appearances in these issues and the Scott and Jean relationship is (of course) central to everything. Because of the Dark Phoenix saga, Scott (Cyclops) is haunted for years.

So yeah...The Dark Phoenix Saga was (and is) a big deal. I wonder if one movie is going to do it justice. My guess is...probably not. But when it eventually comes out, I'll see it anyway. There's so much good story there to mine that it seems like it would be impossible to mess up.


6 comments:

  1. Now that Disney owns the XMen it really doesn't matter. Another reboot is inevitable. And Sophie Turner sucks.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh, but they'll mess it up. You know they will ;)

    Sounds like a good story. Of course the movies will want to mine it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You and Pat pretty much said what I was thinking. The only thing I'd add is teen-aged boys love the idea of a good girl that turns bad. X-men traded in on that but the never-ending focus on Dark Phoenix always kills the series for me. Why can't Sony find a compelling X-Men story outside of Logan and Jean Gray?

    Then there's the problem of Sophie Turner. I really want to like her as she seems nice but her acting in the last X-Men movie was wooden and I really doubt she's up to the task. I'd much rather see one around Storm. I thought that actress (Alexandra Shipp) did a nice job in Apocalypse. Maybe with the Disney purchase of Fox we can see her in Black Panther 2!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ugh. I meant 'Why can't Fox find a compelling X-Men story other than Logan and Jean..." The same thing is true in the cartoons. They have dozens of interesting characters to choose and it always comes back to those two.

      Delete
  4. Just to be clear:
    It's not Marvel making these. It's Fox.

    ReplyDelete
  5. First off, sorry I've missed a couple of your postings. I've now read the last two (just didn't comment).

    I knew nothing about this saga or character, but I appreciate your explanation of what guys who are into this type of comic idealize. Yes, they want the woman to be hot (big shocker!), but I'm relieved and a little happy that at least they also want her to be tough-talking and can kick and punch. Of course, when I was little women were supposed to think of Audrey Hepburn as the best model for us, but I wanted to be Sheena Queen of the Jungle.

    ReplyDelete